Ok, so here it is. I've got a couple of opinions about this, but I'm not, again I say I am NOT claiming to be right. I can be convinced. I'd really love discussion about this, because I just don't get it. There are three main things here that I see: False advertising, Idolatry and Money. Today, I’ll discuss the first one.
I linked the other day to
this church where you can find these
video clips. The ones I first saw were the "U2 Christmas" clips, but they also have Switchfoot, McCartney and Coldplay covers, as well as a few of people acting like the Blue Man Group.
I posted this link and was surprised by some of the comments. I figured a lot of people would dog it, and a few did, but a lot of you said good things about it, whether for the production values or the apparent ministry or other reasons.
Now I have no idea who this church is, but I know I've been to about a thousand like it, so this is BROAD and not SPECIFIC about these people. Some of "those" people may be you, and I'm seriously asking here.
************
My main question is this: Why? Why does a church spend a very large amount of money to be a cover band? Is it to bring people to church who otherwise wouldn't go? Is it to be culturally relevant?
What's the first thing you see when you click on that church's website? The logo for the Fox TV show "24". Why? Turns out they're doing a series based on it. But, not really... They're doing a series based on what the life of a 24/7 Christian looks like. It has nothing to do with the TV show, except for the stolen logo. So why did they do it? Is Jack Bauer preaching? Do they think that I'll see the ad for their "version" of the show and I'll go to their church?
I maintain that this is false advertising. They are obviously using "24" and U2 as advertising. They have graphics and logos and I imagine they're printed up and hanging all over the church, as well as the website. But it's not "24". The pastor isn't disarming a bomb while torturing deacons for vital information. He's talking about Jesus. And I don’t doubt that He is. I've read everything on their site about the beliefs of this Church and they're wonderful. The
notes on the services are full of Scripture. Their
mission statement is doctrinally sound and well-written, so none of that is the issue.
The issue is that they're lying to people so they can tell them the truth.
Again, the message being preached is NOT a rip-off. But the methods are sketchy. I found
this article from the satirical Lark News that illustrates my point. People are coming because of an ad campaign based on a half-truth.
*************
Curt left a comment containing this quote from a wonderful movie called
The Big Kahuna about a salesman who's evangalising instead of doing his job...
“It doesn’t matter whether you’re selling Jesus or Buddha or civil rights or ‘How to Make Money in Real Estate With No Money Down.’ That doesn’t make you a human being; it makes you a marketing rep. If you want to talk to somebody honestly, as a human being, ask him about his kids. Find out what his dreams are–just to find out, for no other reason. Because as soon as you lay your hands on a conversation to steer it, it’s not a conversation anymore; it’s a pitch.�***********
Is the Church a venue or a community of believers? Does seeing your pastor dress up like Bono and shout "Uno, Dos, Tres, Catorce!!" bring you further into your community? It might for you, it really might, but it definitely doesn't for me.
I’m a storyteller. I have no problem with using pop culture as a reference. Illustrations are valuable, and U2’s songs are full of great ones. But do you really have to copy the band’s staging (the red open heart) so somebody understands the spiritual longing in “I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For�? If it’s that great of a song, the point is probably made without the light show. In fact, seeing your pastor huffing it around the stage dressed like a rock star makes the depth of the lyric a little harder to focus on, I’d imagine.
*************
It’s the thing to do these days to make the church look like a rock show, but really, that’s ridiculous.
I was in Atlanta at a YouthSpecialties conference with Caedmon’s a couple years ago. 7000 or so youth group leaders and pastors were there to catch up on the hottest tools and trends. Cliff took a moment to point out what should be obvious. “We will never be as cool as MTV,� he told them. “They set the definition of cool, and we spend too much time chasing it. What MTV doesn’t have is the love of Jesus.� We were told we’ll never be asked back by YouthSpecialties.
But that is the truth. MTV may have cool, but it doesn’t have the love of Jesus. Every single person in this world lives near somebody else. It doesn’t take a lot of cool to love my neighbor, but it often takes a lot of time and effort, (and it’s never as glamorous as 15 minutes of getting to be The Edge.)
For 2000 years people have been coming into their local church meetings. Every soul has a void and a longing for the world to make sense, for the pain to be healed. The Church has what fills that void. We can cover U2 to fill some seats, and Kiefer Sutherland could baptize people on video screens, but it doesn’t matter. People will come to Church because that’s where they look when they want to find Jesus.
What do you think? Agree? Disagree? Am I missing something important? Has your life been changed for the better by things like this? I've got opinions for days, but it doesn't mean they're always right...